Detroit’s City Council is seriously reconsidering how it approaches middle-income housing development relief applications.
WHAT HAPPENED?
Two contentious applications for Standard Workforce Housing project PILOTs (“Payment in Lieu of Taxes”) were approved Tuesday for developments in Midtown and near Eastern Market/Downtown. The applications originally were voted down last week, have taken up significant portions of the last two formal sessions, and even resulted in Council Member Scott Benson pushing to suspend part of the rule allowing council members to reconsider their votes to make sure it would pass more smoothly.
WHAT ARE PILOTs?
A PILOT is a tax incentive aimed at growing affordable housing in Detroit, primarily by keeping rent down. Developers can qualify for the program if they invest a certain minimum into a property development, and commit to restricting rents for tenants within a certain income bracket while the PILOT lasts. They also must maintain “good standing” with the city, and comply with city regulations, like having certificates of compliance or occupancy from the Buildings, Safety Engineering, and Environmental Department.
PILOTs work by allowing developers to pay a percentage of the rents they collect yearly instead of standard property taxes — or, as the name suggests, payments in lieu of taxes. This is generally more affordable for developers, who would otherwise be paying taxes that have become increasingly high in Detroit, especially when taxes are “uncapped” following the year after a building is purchased or ownership is transferred.
There are different kinds of PILOTs, but the one City Council contended with recently is the Standard Workforce Housing PILOT, which requires City Council approval before being granted to a developer. SWHPs target moderate- or middle-income household growth. This typically includes residents like teachers, firefighters, bus drivers, nurses and more who earn within a certain range — above 80% to 120% — of Detroit area’s average median income, or AMI.
A change in Michigan housing legislation (PA 239) in 2022 allowed cities like Detroit to dictate their own PILOT policies and approvals. City council later adopted a PILOT ordinance in 2024.
WHAT IS THE DEBATE?
Detroiters pay one of the highest effective property tax rates in the nation, leading major cities in the US. When taxes go up, rents tend to go up, pricing people out of housing. Like other abatements, PILOTs are supposed to help encourage development and growth, while also helping new residents to move in or existing residents stay where they are. PILOTs can also be important to helping grow needed wealth diversity in an area by providing affordable housing for moderate and middle income earners who might otherwise go to the suburbs.
While the City Council seems mostly united on the importance of increasing affordable housing options in Detroit, reservations — and more than a little confusion — about PILOTs in general seem to persist.
Some council members were opposed to these specific PILOTs because they did not feel like the need was properly demonstrated, especially given all the work still needed on low-income housing options and aid. Others have begun seeing PILOTs as a bailout for landlords and developers. A few council members also noted frustrations about not having enough time to take in information and weigh their options, given the short weeks they had between when the issue was introduced in a council subcommittee and when the full council was expected to vote.
Even District 3 Council Member Scott Benson, the most vocal supporter of the PILOT developments that the council was voting on, has acknowledged that the limitations of PILOTs and his own desire to see amendments to the ordinance. PILOTs are not the main answer to chronic affordability issues in Detroit. But they are one of the few options City Council is empowered to act on, said Chase Cantrell, executive director of Building Community Value, a development nonprofit.
“It’s a Band-Aid,” said Cantrell in an interview with BridgeDetroit. “The true fix is to fix our property tax system. It’s to bring our millage (rate) down, but that requires Lansing. The city can’t do it by itself. So instead, what the city can do, and unfortunately has to do, is to figure out how and when to give these incentives and these abatements.”
WHAT’S HAPPENING NEXT?
Two items — one related to evaluating the PILOT program and current developments and the other related to potentially modifying the current PILOT ordinance — are now in the Budget, Finance and Audit Committee.
The memos, which are from City Council President James Tate and Benson respectively, made their first appearance on the BFA agenda Oct. 28. The memos are currently awaiting responses from several city departments, and the committee has scheduled to bring them back in three weeks.
Editor’s note: This story has been updated since publication to incorporate new information.
