Detroit’s City Council delayed action Tuesday on the proposed $2.2 billion makeover of the Renaissance Center and East Riverfront as members and residents continue to press developers on unanswered questions and improved benefits like more job guarantees, public ownership of land next to the towers, and more.
City Council President James Tate announced the panel’s intention to postpone votes on the package of vital tax incentives and proposed community benefits at the top of the packed meeting.
Still, much of public comment was dominated by residents, advocates, newly elected State Rep. Chris Gilmer-Hill of Michigan’s 8th House District and two Detroit Police Commissioners weighing in on the redevelopment.
Here are the highlights:
COMMUNITY QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, CONCERNS?

The 100-plus public commenters ran a gamut of familiar celebrations, concerns, questions and critiques.
- Support for the project was mostly voiced by development, union and construction interests. Other supporters spoke about the proposed economic benefits of the project for residents and working Detroiters, as well as the positive legacy it could leave future generations.
- The people pushing back continue to argue for more concrete and enforceable promises from developers that would bring direct benefits to Detroiters. This includes solid plans for things like the marina, maintaining the remaining affordable living downtown and environmental concerns tied to the deconstruction of two of the five RenCen towers. Most called on council members to delay voting, or at least to “delay and improve” the community benefits agreement.
- Folks from both sides were grateful for the delay, and had critiques about how fast the community benefits process has been and that it’s already in front of the full council for consideration.
During a Monday community meeting about the project hosted by Council Member Mary Waters there was a more firm and specific public ownership demand from organizers with Detroit People’s Platform. They are asking the development team to donate 18 acres of land next to the RenCen to the city and an endowment to help pay for maintenance and upkeep. The developers have referred to the land as “civic space,” which is committed to be accessible. However, advocates say there’s uncertainty over what would happen with this space after the tax abatement being sought for the project ends.
Between Waters’ Monday meeting and Tuesday’s council session, there were also concerns about transparency and accountability, especially when it came to a confidential Law Department memo on community ownership.
WHERE DO THE COUNCIL MEMBERS STAND?
While there is technically no deadline for council to vote, developers have spoken about their urgency in advancing the deal so they can secure state-level approvals from the Michigan Strategic Fund.Bedrock representative Steve Ogden implied Monday that part of the developers’ urgency stems from wanting to get the local approvals before Democratic Gov.-Elect Jocelyn Benson takes office in January. Ogden said both Benson and her former opponent, Republican John James, “are on record saying they want to blow up” the Michigan Economic Development Corporation, the public-private partnership crated to carry out MSF programs. Ogden said potential MEDC changes could result in delays for the development timeline.

President Pro Tem Coleman A. Young II, who recently touted the public benefits of the project, told BridgeDetroit after Tuesday’s meeting he was ready to vote ‘yes’ on the RenCen proposals, and expected votes as soon as next week. Meanwhile, Council Member Gabriela Santiago-Romeromaintained her position of bringing the measures back in the new year.
Tate and Council Members Angela Whitfield-Calloway and Scott Benson were largely focused on getting questions answered, and letting those answers and community input to shape their votes. Along with other council members, the three received answers to memos on a variety of issues like East Riverfront ownership, Gilbert’s $1 billion nonprofit which would manage and own the redevelopment, the proposed abatement structures (like payments-in-lieu-of-taxes) developers are seeking and more. Waters on Monday echoed similar sentiments and said that she wanted to work with developers, especially on potentially increasing benefits for businesses.
“Now I get my opportunity to say to Bedrock, ‘Okay, but can we do A? Can we do B? Can we do C?’ Just to kind of help pump up the benefits and put some of our residents at ease,” Waters said. “To let folks know that we care, we hear you, we see you.”
Representatives for council members Renata Miller and Latisha Johnson declined comment on their behalf after Tuesday’s meeting. Council Member Denzell McCampbell could not be reached Tuesday evening.
WHAT HAPPENS NOW AND HOW CAN I BE INVOLVED?
There are two key meetings for this issue remaining before the council goes on winter recess starting Nov. 25.
→ Thursday’s Planning and Economic Development subcommittee is slated to feature remaining and new memos from council members. You can attend at 10 a.m. at the Coleman A. Young Municipal Center, or virtually here. Watch the city calendar for the agenda and other items here.
→ The Council could vote at next Tuesday’s formal council meeting. You can attend 10 a.m. at the Coleman A. Young Municipal Center council auditorium, or virtually here. Watch the city calendar for the agenda and other items here.=
