Detroit Board of Police Commissioners meeting from Oct. 29, 2026. Credit: Jasmine Snow, BridgeDetroit

Detroit’s police oversight board has regained direct access to police camera footage after months of relying on the discretion of the department it’s meant to hold accountable.

Investigators with Detroit’s Board of Police Commissioners can once again directly access raw police camera footage after the Detroit Police Department stripped BOPC’s full access to body and dashboard camera recordings and certain records on May 15. Since then, the board — which is responsible for independent civilian oversight of DPD — had to rely on partially redacted footage, records and reports from the police department. 

Prior to the process change in the spring, the BOPC investigators had been able to independently access a slew of DPD records since the board’s establishment in 1974. 

Detroit Police Chief Todd Bettison was responsible for revoking — and, recently, restoring — access. But, between police commissioners, their investigators, the city’s top attorney Conrad Mallett and Bettison himself, confusion persists over why access was restricted to begin with.

The board has argued that the restrictions impaired BOPC’s ability to carry out its charter-mandated duties and slowed the work of its investigative arm, which has grappled for years with a citizen complaint backlog. There are currently more than  2,000 open complaints, according to the board’s Police Accountability Dashboard. It was not immediately clear exactly how many reports were delayed due to the May process change. 

The BOPC’s Office of the Chief Investigator, led by Jerome Warfield, investigates non-criminal citizen complaints against the Detroit Police Department. Warfield served on the board from 2009 to 2013, and has been the chief investigator since 2023. During that time, Warfield told BridgeDetroit, there has never been a leak from the office, nor has the OCI been accused of “infringing upon the privilege that we have of using sensitive information to do our investigation.”  

“Imagine, if you will, the prosecutor had to go to the perpetrator and said, ‘Could you send me some proof that you did the crime that you are accused of doing?’” said Warfield, calling the process of restricting BOPC access a “muddled mess.”

“That’s how ludicrous this is to me; that we’re asking the ones who are being accused to send us evidence that they are in control of,” he said.

Previously, OCI investigators could log in via a computer or use a cellphone app to directly access raw data or footage. The spring process change meant investigators had to request certain DPD footage and that sensitive data was redacted by DPD officers before it was turned over. 

Bettison said that he ultimately made the decision to restore BOPC’s access after receiving conflicting guidance about who had authority over the process.

“Then, it was told to me that I had the decision, and it was on me whether or not I would restore it or not,” Bettison told commissioners at Thursday’s meeting. “And so, if the power is mine to restore it, when I was told it wasn’t mine initially, then I restored it.”

Bettison did not explicitly say where his initial direction came from. The chief declined BridgeDetroit’s request to comment following the meeting. 

According to Warfield and a June statement from board commissioners, the BOPC was told direct access to footage had to end due to compliance issues with FBI policies for handling sensitive criminal justice and public safety information. These rules are set forth by the bureau’s Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) Division, a criminal justice “hub” that manages databases where the records are stored. The sensitive information — often referred to as “CJIS data,” — can be included in records found in the databases that the OCI has historically had direct access to. Police camera footage, for example, is sometimes roped in because it can capture things like police computer terminals, which can sometimes contain CJIS data. 

Police commissioners said in the June statement that they felt the push was coming from the FBI, in conjunction with the Michigan Commission on Law Enforcement Standards, or MCOLES, housed within the Michigan State Police Department. This was based on a private May 4 virtual meeting commissioners and Warfield have said was attended by representatives from MSP, MCOLES and the FBI. Agencies found to be noncompliant with CJIS Security Policy are subject to “restriction, suspension, or termination of CJIS access,” according to the board’s statement. 

Warfield and several police commissioners have said Bettison has been very supportive of maintaining BOPC’s full access to police footage and records since May. Warfield reiterated at Thursday’s meeting that Bettison tried on multiple occasions during the May 4 meeting to work with the FBI and state agencies on proposals that would maintain access — all of which were shot down by the federal and state law enforcement officials, according to Warfield and the commissioners.

According to a Thursday statement from the FBI, its officials attended the May meeting at the request of MSP, the body responsible for administering statewide use of CJIS programs and enforcing the rules. 

“However, the FBI did not direct or make decisions regarding the Detroit Board of Police Commissioners access to body cam footage as the matter falls outside the scope of the FBI’s CJIS Division,” the emailed statement to BridgeDetroit notes.

In a Friday statement emailed to BridgeDetroit, MSP also confirmed it was not responsible for the decision to strip BOPC of direct access. Although, MSP said it has been “consistent in its stance” for “many years” that BOPC and OCI are not eligible for access to CJIS systems and the data that they hold. BOPC, the statement notes, is considered a non-criminal justice entity, and its Charter-based “oversight” capacity, “is not a criminal justice function according to state and federal law.” Because DPD is the authorized agency for the records and databases, MSP adds, it’s DPD’s responsibility to ensure that data is not unlawfully disseminated. 

Warfield said at Thursday’s meeting that OCI investigators’ requests had never been strictly denied by DPD. But the change slowed investigations, often requiring multiple rounds of communication between investigators and the officers responsible for fulfilling their requests. On some occasions, Warfield said, investigators were told footage was not available and later found out that it had been. He also told BridgeDetroit that in addition to being fingerprinted and undergoing extensive background checks upon hiring, OCI investigators are “CJIS-certified.” 

“It seems like we were bamboozled at the end of the day,” said Warfield. “So it’s hard to say, and no one wants to take responsibility.”  

When BridgeDetroit asked about the OCI investigators’ CJIS-certified status, an MSP public information officer referred back to the original statement. 

MCOLES Executive Director Tim Bourgeois said in a Friday statement that MCOLES has “no statutory authority over the topic at hand,” and took no part in the process. 

Restored access doesn’t resolve broader concerns

Despite some restored access, the OCI still lacks direct access to multiple systems and reports it previously had, Warfield said Thursday.

It’s unclear how, when or whether that access will be restored. Commissioners are also concerned that nothing is in place to prevent access from being stripped again in the future. 

District 3 Commissioner Darious Morris, who was not at Thursday’s meeting, previously told BridgeDetroit that the access restrictions undermined civilian oversight, which “kills transparency” and weakens the ability to hold people accountable. 

“We need the information to know what’s going on and to be able to root out misconduct and move them toward accountability,” he said. “So it (restricting access to information) was like taking the legs from up under us.”

Still, some commissioners and community members view the restored camera footage access as a significant, if partial, victory. 

“Certainly I’m relieved that some of that access has been restored,” District 7 Commissioner Victoria Camille, who has been one of the most publicly outspoken commissioners on the issue, said at Thursday’s meeting. 

“…We should continue to advocate for the remainder of that access to be restored, and for whatever necessary reforms have to happen at the state and federal level to ensure that threats like this don’t prevail, even temporarily, for any other civilian oversight agency,” she said.

Warfield told BridgeDetroit Thursday that looking back, “we should have fought,” when direct access was revoked. During Thursday’s meeting, Warfield said more formal paperwork might be needed in the future to ensure “this doesn’t happen again.” Mallett previously raised the possible need for similar agreements when discussing the restoration of OCI access. 

Frequent BOPC meeting attendee Eric Blount, Minister at Sacred Heart Catholic Church, told BridgeDetroit his trust in DPD and the other involved agencies has been impacted by the “smoke and mirrors” that allowed access to be revoked in the first place.

“You don’t know what to believe, and therefore, how can you trust them?” Blount said “…When you lose trust, you begin to question everything.” 

Jasmine C. Snow covers Detroit City Council and produces the Detroit City Notebook for BridgeDetroit. She was previously a lead research assistant with the LIFT Project, a research organization working...

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *