A rendering of the Renaissance Center footprint post redevelopment where two of the towers would be torn down.
A rendering of the Renaissance Center footprint post-redevelopment. Credit: Courtesy of Bedrock-Gensler-Field Operations

In response to the Nov. 14 opinion piece entitled We should delay GM, Bedrock’s plans for Detroit’s Riverfront, we want to clarify misconceptions about the Community Benefits Ordinance process and the proposed agreement before the Detroit City Council.

The piece was written by the only Renaissance Center/East Riverfront Neighborhood Advisory Committee (NAC) member who voted against our historic community benefits agreement.

The NAC had many marathon work sessions lasting more than eight to 10 hours, and we went into the process knowing that. We made a commitment to participate because Detroit and Detroiters deserved such an effort. 

With our mission to serve our city as our only motivation, none of us were intimidated by those we sat across the table from in negotiations. The city of Detroit’s Planning Department, which was present at every marathon meeting, did an amazing job providing policy support where needed, as well as making the entire administration and its subject matter experts available to us upon request. 

As the NAC, our assignment was simple and practical: negotiate a community impact and benefits agreement on behalf of Detroiters. That was our focus. Our assignment was never to reject or reshape this project. Nor was it to focus on development timelines, construction or operational costs. 

As the NAC, we never believed public transit was the responsibility of this developer. We all saw public transit as an issue for local, state and federal government to address. The city agreed with us.

We understand the $300 million commitment to this project isn’t a “blank check” to developers or a “check” at all. And it isn’t a loan to be paid back to the city. It is an investment – by the Michigan Strategic Fund – to save, arguably, Detroit’s most iconic building. The $174 million in tax abatements isn’t a “check” either. It’s simply a discount on future taxes that not only do not currently exist today but will never exist if this project isn’t built. And above all, we understand the developer gets none of these financial commitments if the project is not completed and operating at projected levels. 

We understand the “taxes” from this project were never going to be withdrawn from or deposited into the city’s general fund. Whether the developer received tax incentives or not, the taxes from this project would/will be collected by the Downtown Development Authority, not the city – by law. 

We understand that technically, the city’s only role in this process is to evaluate and approve this project to allow the state to invest the funds into the RenCen development, while leveraging this economic opportunity to create both construction and permanent jobs for Detroiters, affordable housing, neighborhood investment, workforce training and Detroit-based business inclusion for Detroit residents, among other things. 

Therefore, we see the risk of this project differently than our sole colleague.

What we consider at risk is an investor willing to make a $1.6 billion investment to reimagine the Renaissance Center; a half billion-dollar investment to Detroit by the Michigan Strategic Fund; a $95 million up front payment to the city to be used immediately to improve city services; an extra $300 million to the city over the course of construction period to do the same; the $113 million in community benefits (including $43.5 million in direct monetary benefits) that we negotiated in our agreement; and the more than $3 billion in economic activity that Detroit will enjoy for years to come after this project is complete. 

Let us be clear: None of this takes place without this project. 

Therefore, we, the undersigned members of the Neighborhood Advisory Council, not only stand by the historic community benefits agreement that we negotiated; we see no reason to delay this project from moving forward. 

Editor’s note: This story was written by Jamaine Dickens, the chair of the NAC, on behalf of the board, which includes Bernard Morgan II, Vice Chair; Jeff Mastej, Parliamentarian; Deirdre Jackson; Gail Perry Mason; Linda Middlebrooks Talbot; Aloshia Jackson; and Patrice Woodard. All members listed signed off.

Jamaine Dickens is the principal of Compass Strategies, a public affairs firm in Detroit. He is the former spokesperson for the City of Detroit, and former communications director for the Michigan Legislature. He is currently serving as the chair of the Neighborhood Advisory Council for the Renaissance Center/East Riverfront project.

Jamaine Dickens is the principal of Compass Strategies, a public affairs firm in Detroit. He is the former spokesperson for the City of Detroit, and former communications director for the Michigan Legislature....

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *